Nestled in a peaceful corner of Amagansett, New York, a one-of-a-kind historical treasure – a windmill – remains on the market, waiting for its new owner. This is the very spot where Marilyn Monroe and playwright Arthur Miller sought refuge from the press in the 1950s. The asking price for this unique piece of history is $12 million.
The two-story windmill, featuring two bedrooms and one bathroom, first hit the market in 2013 and has been relisted since 2019. Despite being available for over a decade, the price has remained largely unchanged, a testament to the owner’s patience, according to the listing agent.
Originally built in 1830, the windmill sits on a stunning 5.45-acre lot. The current asking price of $12 million is just $500,000 more than its initial listing, with the owner confident in its value. The rarity of large 5-acre lots in Amagansett, combined with inflation, makes the price seem reasonable, the seller asserts. The land offers the potential for a grand mansion, and the windmill itself holds historical significance.
Inside the three-story structure, some of the windmill’s original mechanical components have been preserved. The property is unfenced, allowing wildlife to roam freely through its forested landscape. With thoughtful design, the windmill could be preserved as a guest house or seamlessly integrated into a new estate, blending history with modern luxury. Unlike decorative windmills found in some architectural designs, this one is a genuine, historical artifact.
As the historic windmill in the Hamptons awaits its next chapter, it remains to be seen whether it will become part of a lavish mansion or continue to stand as a quiet witness to history, its wings gently turning in the breeze.
